Monthly Archives: November 2011

No to compulsory history.


David Cannadine, a British historian, is proposing that history be made a compulsory subject until the age of 18. We ought to have wide choice in education. I do not mean taking this to the fair. Some things are not academic subjects and should not be degree bearing for instance.

My point is that history should be compulsory up until the age oof 14. Some people are not good at the subject and and hate it. They should not be forced to carry on with something that is non-essential. It can be useful to some people in that it gives them skills and gives them a context to careers such as law. Some people will make minimal progress in history after the age of 14. They would be much better off making headway in a subject for which they have an aptitude and that they actually like.

I wish this permanent revolution in British education would stop. Change this, change that, change the other thing then change it back again, then change it forward again. Ok let’s have a complete rethink. Total change. Then minor change back. Then a new royal commission. Then change to what we had in the interim.

Invent a decent system and then stick to it. Stop fiddling with the system.

A dream of swimming lions in Burma.


I was walking through an old quarter of a Middle Eastern city. More than likely it was the old city here in Boratistan. The sandstone was all a tan colour and very well preserved. I was accompanied by my aged parents. My father wore a T shirt and white shorts. He had on the panama hat he used to wear when I visited him in Australia in 2007. Then I sucked my finger. He took umbrage at that and walked off down a street. This reflects the worry I have about upsetting him. He is so easily offended and sulks for years.

What then? I walked in through the gate of a hotel in a tropical land. I walked into the lobby of the smart hotel. Ot was marble floors and the reception desk was like that too. The receptionist looked up but she did not acknowledge me – she was young and moody – a brunette.

Later I walked around the swimming pool by the premiere wall. I did not ppayu any attention to the peop;e in the pool. huit there woyre but I did not pau any attention to them. A young woman under a tree offered me a spiff. I took one drag. She asked me to buy it. I did not. She was white and a brunette -decenet looking. She was unsmiling and wore a black T shirt. I declined and hurried on. She followed me. Some paces later two policeman greeted me. They wore shades and were brown – Pakistanis or something. They were sophistcated. I feared they would arrest me for nput buying the cannabis. They excorted me to the gate. Theyw ere not threatening as I feared they would be..

I left the hotel and walked around the permiter wall as it curved to the right.

Then I got to the walls above the sea. It looked like Dubrovnik but I knew I was in Burma. The scene was serene and the waves rolled gently. There was a fairly bust road to my left. Then I saw some lions swimming in the sea towards me. They did not look aggressive but I wanted out of there. I turned and ran. Then I heard a radio announcement saying that the lions were on the loose.

What can it all mean? My mum urges me to tell my dada that I will stuyd law throygh Dublin University.

I thought of Burma the other night. The democracy movement was crusged there in 2007. I thought of that last night. The Burmese government squashed opposition there and Damascus has not managed to do so now.

Azerbaijan in the First World War.


Azerbaijan in the First World War.

The Russian Empire included Azerbaijan from the late eighteenth century to 1918. Often people simply say Russia when referring to that time period and they mean all the countries that had been absorbed by Russia such as Azerbaijan.

In 1914 a huge war broke out that became known as the First World War. On one side were the Allies: France, the United Kingdom, Russia, Serbia, Belgium and others. On the other side were the Central Powers: Germany, Austria-Hungary, the Ottoman Empire (based around Turkey) and Bulgaria.

At that time most of Africa and Asia were colonies of European countries. France and the United Kingdom ruled many colonies around the world but Germany, Belgium, Italy and Portugal also had overseas colonies. Even some Caribbean islands were colonies of France, the United Kingdom and the Netherlands.



Most Azeris did not like Russian rule. The Russian Government emphasised that Christianity, especially the Orthodox Church, was central to Russian identity. Most people in Russia could not read and write. Most people in Azerbaijan could not speak Russian and so they were denied government jobs. Azeris tended to take their Islamic faith very seriously at the time. The vodka drinking, pork-eating habits of the Russians horrified some of the more religious Azeris. It was also common for Azeri women to wear a veil. The Russian Government had little respect for Islam.

Azerbaijan was not considered very important for Russia until the 1850s. Until that time Azerbaijan was just seen as some territory for Russia to get so that the Ottoman Empire did not get it. The Ottoman Empire and Russia were deadly enemies who went to war against each other seven times in 200 years. The Azeri language has a lot in common with Turkish. Although 90% of Azeri Muslims are SHia Muslims and Turkish Muslims are 99% Sunni both nationalities are at least Muslim. They have that much in common. Surely Azeris and Turks have a lot more in common with each other than Azeris have in common with the Russians.

Russians were inclined to see Turks as enemies but Azeris were not.

In the 1850s oil was discovered in Azerbaijan. This was not incredibly important at first because coal was more important. Coal was used for burning to heat houses, for burning to turn water into steam to make ships and trains run. Coal was also used to power factories. However, some machinery began to switch over to oil. In 1885 a German named Otto Benz invented the car and it needed oil. At first cars were extraordinarily expensive and almost nobody had them. Gradually more cars, buses and trucks were built. Oil became more important. Some ships changed from using coal to using oil. By 1914 oil was almost as important as coal as a fuel source. Azerbaijan had strategic value.

If you look at fine buildings in Baku you will see the dates on them. Many date from the years shortly before the First World War. Baku was undergoing and oil boom. Until the 1850s Baku had been a small port and was not the capital. It assumed great importance because of oil. Russians flooded into the city and Baku expanded rapidly. The oil workers, railwaymen, factory workers and government officials were almost all Russian or Ukrainian. People tended not to distinguish between Russians and Ukrainians at the time because the Ukraine was simply regarded as part of Russia.

Mammad Amin Rasulzade was an Azeri nationalist activist before the First World War. Rasulzade wanted Azerbaijan to break away from Russia which he saw as totally foreign. He founded a political party called the Musavat Party. This political party was illegal and existed secretly. The Musavat Party wanted Azerbaijan to unite with Turkey and all other countries that spoke a language similar to Turkish. The Musavat Party was a secular party. That means it believed that religion should be a private matter. A secularist says that everyone can believe in any religion they want and that the government should not support or oppose any religion. Secularism was quite a daring idea at the time. Almost every country had a government that supported a particular religion. In Russian Orthodox Christianity was the state religion and the Orthodox Church was given special privileges. Orthodox Christians were more trusted than people who belonged to other types of Christianity or indeed who were Muslims or Jews. In the Ottoman Empire Islam was the state religion and the law was based on the Qu’ran which is the holy book of the Muslims.



The Tsar of Russia at the time was Nicholas II. He was not a man who was born with great leadership skills. It is hard to find a historian who praises him. The country was not ready for a war. Within a month of going to war Russia suffered a heavy defeat by the German Army at the Battle of Tannenberg.

The Ottoman Empire was then most of the Middle East. It comprised what we now call Turkey, Iraq, Syria, Jordan, Israel, Palestine, Lebanon and parts of Saudi Arabia. Turkish was the official language of this empire but most of its people spoke Arabic as their first language. About 90% of the people of the Ottoman Empire was Muslims and practically all the rest were Christians. The Ottoman Empire was neutral for the first few months. However, the Ottoman Navy bombarded the Russian Black Sea Coast. Russia declared war on the Ottoman Empire.

Soon there was fighting in the Caucasus. Ottoman troops fought against Russian troops. Many of the Russian soldiers were not really Russian. Many of them came from the non-Russian parts of the Russian Empire such as Finland, Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia, eastern Poland, Kazakstan, Georgia and so on.

Some of Armenia was part of the Russian Empire and some of it was part of the Ottoman Empire. Armenians, being Christians, tended to look to Russia as their protector against the Ottomans. Armenians in the Ottoman Empire rebelled against Ottoman rule. The rebellion was defeated and many were killed. The Armenian civilians were forcibly moved to Syria. Many of them died along the way. This is one of the most controversial chapters in the First Word War. How many Armenian civilians died? Were they deliberately killed or was it accidental? Did Armenians kill Ottoman civilians in great numbers too? People argue hotly over this terrible episode even today.

Central Asian countries were part of the Russian Empire: Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan and Tajikistan. People in these countries were almost all Muslim and spoke Turkic languages. They had no natural connection to the Russian people. As the Russian military was busy fighting in the west people in Central Asia saw that this was a good opportunity for them to rebel. The rebellions in Central Asia were aimed at these countries becoming independent. The Russian Army was having a very hard time fighting in Europe. Millions of Russian soldiers had been killed, wounded or captured. Many Russian soldiers grew demoralised. They did not think that they could win and they did not think that their system of government was worth fighting for. Some Russian soldiers deserted.

The Bolsheviks were a political party in Russia. The Bolsheviks hated the Tsar and the whole political and economic system of Russia. The Bolsheviks thought that every government in the world was run to benefit a small number of rich people and this caused misery for the majority who were poor. The Bolsheviks based their beliefs on a books by a German thinker called Karl Marx. Marx died in 1883 but his ideas were still very influential in 1917. Karl Marx’s views are known as communism because of his most famous book, ”the Communist Manifesto.”.

The Bolsheviks disliked all religions believing that all religions were false. They said that religion was a way of the rich fooling the poor into being obedient. The Bolsheviks also disliked the whole idea of national pride.

Bolsheviks told soldiers and sailors that the war was not worth fighting. They encouraged soldiers to desert. The Bolsheviks said that the war was fought for the advantage of rich people on both sides. Ordinary working people on both sides were being slaughtered in their millions. The Bolsheviks pointed out that while civilians starved in the war and soldiers were shot some people were getting rich from the war. Those who owned the factories that made military uniforms or bullets did very well out of the war.

In Azerbaijan the Bolsheviks spread their ideas among Russian speaking oil workers. The Bolsheviks were active in Baku but hardly anywhere else. The Bolsheviks made their views known in cities but were not effective in the countryside.

In February 1917 protests began in St Petersburg which was then the Russian capital. These protests became known as the February Revolution. The protests became so massive that generals and admirals withdrew support for the Tsar. Nicholas II abdicated which means he gave up being the Tsar. There would be no more imperial family. Russia became a republic. A republic is not ruled by a king or queen but by an emperor.

A Provisional Government took over the Russian Empire, including Azerbaijan. The Provisional Government decided to continue the war. Germany and Austria-Hungary were still occupying a lot of Russian territory in the west. Germany and Austria-Hungary did not show any sign of giving up this land. Therefore Russia was going to have to fight to get it back. If Russia did not fight then the German Army and the Austro-Hungarian Army would only advance further east and take even more territory.

The war went from bad to worse for Russia. Russia continued to suffer terrible defeats and soldiers deserted at an alarming rate. Many peasants seized land from the rich. This had an effect on people in Azerbaijan too. The food situation in Russia grew worse and worse. Many farmers had gone off to war so not enough men were left to produce food. Trains were being used by the army. Trains and railways used to distribute food were not repaired enough during the war and many became unusable.

The Bolshevik Party spread its views assiduously. Lenin, the leader of the Bolsheviks, had been living abroad for years. He had spent most of his time in Switzerland. Lenin was determined to pull Russia out of the war. He saw this war as massacring the working classes of all countries just to make the rich even richer. The German Government hated Lenin’s revolutionary views but they thought that getting Russia out of the war was very good for Germany. The fewer enemies, the better.

The German Government put Lenin on a train from Switzerland through Germany and then on a boat to Finland – which was Russian territory.

Lenin arrived in St Petersburg in April 1917. He immediately began to spread his revolutionary views. Russia must withdraw from the war straightaway. The property of the rich must be taken away and shared by the poor. Then ordinary people would have enough to eat. His views became very popular.

In October 1917 the Bolsheviks in St Petersburg launched an attempt to seize power. This is called the October Revolution. The Bolsheviks took control of St Petersburg quite easily. However, in the rest of Russia they had much more difficulty. This caused the Russian Civil War to break out. The Bolsheviks were identified with the colour red. Those who were against the Bolsheviks were identified with the colour white. The Civil War was reds against whites.

The Russian Civil War was also fought between red and white factions in Azerbaijan. Many Azeris believed that the Russian Civil War was a Russian dispute and Azerbaijan should stay out of it. Some Azeris were inspired by the Central Asian rebellions. Kazakhs, Turkmens and Uzbeks fought for independence. Maybe Azerbaijan ought to do the same.

Lenin said that he would like non-Russian parts of the former Russian Empire to form a ”voluntary and honourable union. ” Poland, Finland, Latvia, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan and so on could remain united with Russia. Lenin promised that if they did so all religions and nationalities would be treated equally. Lenin said that if the people of these non-Russian countries wished to go independent then this wish would be respected.

The Whites in the Russian Civil War tended to believe that the Russian Empire must remain united – by force if necessary. Azerbaijan, Georgia, Estonia, Finland, Tajikistan – they must all stay with Russia. They must not be allowed the choice to be independent.

Because the Reds backed the principle of Azeri independence and the Whites opposed it this meant that for Azeri nationalists a Red victory would be better than a White victory. On the other hands the Reds were anti-religious. The Whites were Christians almost to a man but did not propose to ban Islam.



The Sultan of the Ottoman Empire claimed to the Caliph. The Caliph is the successor to the Prophet Mohammad. Many Muslims looked up to the Ottoman Sultan for this reason.

Arabs during the First World War were encouraged to be aware of their Arab identity by the Allies. An Arab Revolt against the Ottoman Empire started. France and the United Kingdom supported this rebellion.

The Ottomans hit upon the idea of appealing to Muslims to unite with them. They especially hoped to win support from the Turkic peoples of Central Asia – Kazakhs, Turkmens, Tajiks and so on. They asked Azeris to support them too. As the Ottoman Empire in Arabia collapsed maybe a greater Turkey could be built in Central Asia.

The Army of Islam was formed. It proposed to help Azerbaijan win independence.

On 28 May 1918 a meeting of Azeri nationalists was held at Ganja. They declared Azerbaijan to be an independent democratic republic. They stated that Azerbaijan was a secular country. That means that people were free to practise any religion they wanted or to practise no religion at all. The government was not for or against any religion. The law of the land would not be based on any religious text. Women were given the right to vote – this was rather ahead of its time. Azerbaijan adopted the blue, red and green flag with the eight pointed white star and white crescent moon.

The 28 May metro station is named in honour of this significant event.

Baku was still in Russian hands. An uneasy truce was worked out between the Red and White factions in the city.

The Russian Civil War was raging. The western Allies were desperate to keep Russia in the war against Germany. The western Allies needed all the help they could get to beat Germany. Allied countries sent soldiers to help the Whites. These were British, American, Canadian, Australian, Serbian, Italian, French and Japanese. These were not large numbers of troops. Their role was supposed to be to train the Whites and not to fight for them.

British soldiers arrived in Baku under General Dunsterville.

Armenia also declared independence. There was a large Armenian population in Azerbaijan especially in Baku. Armenians in Azerbaijan formed armed groups partly for self-protection. However, some of them murdered Azeri civilians.

In August 1918 the Army of Islam entered Azerbaijan with the intent of helping the Azeri independence fighters win control of Baku.



Baku was garrisoned by a bizarre mixture of British troops, White Russians, Red Russians and Armenian nationalists. This rag tag army was called Dunsterforce because it was commanded by Gen Dunsterville.

The Army of Islam attacked Baku in August 1918. By September 1918 Dunsterforce was defeated. Dunsterville and his men escaped in a ship across the Caspian.

The Democratic Republic of Azerbaijan was now a reality. It controlled all the territory of modern day Azerbaijan. However, Azerbaijan was in a very dangerous situation. The White Russians would like to regain Azerbaijan. For the moment the Whites were engaged in a civil war against the Reds. The Reds, at that time, said they wished independent Azerbaijan well. The Army of Islam was there to supposedly help the Azeris. There was a suspicion in the minds of some Azeris that the Army of Islam was intended to force Azerbaijan to unite with Turkey. The Army of Islam was perhaps using the name ‘Islam’ to hide its true purpose – Turkish expansionism.

Many Azeris looked back to the time when north-west Iran was part of Azerbaijan. The Azeris of Iran comrpise around a third of the population of Iran. Tabriz, now in Iran, was once the capital of Greater Azerbaijan. Iran viewed Azeri independence as a threat.

Azerbaijan’s main export earner was oil. International trade had all but stopped owing to the world war. Trade with Russia was almost impossible because of the horrendous civil war there. Most people in Azerbaijan had been reduced to dire poverty.

In November 1918 the First World War ended. The Allies then met in Paris to decide what terms to impose on the defeated Central Powers countries. Azerbaijan sent a delegation.

The Ottoman Empire lost all of its territory outside modern Turkey. Some Turkish leaders went to Central Asia to try and create a massive Turkic State there.

In 1919 The Allies withdrew their soldiers from Russia. The Reds were already winning the Civil War. The fact that foreign troops were no longer supporting the Whites meant that the White slide toward defeat became even faster.


Lenin was the ruler of Russia under the Reds. He did not use the title Prime Minister although in fact his position was roughly the same as Prime Minister. Lenin’s title was Chairman of the Council of People’s Commissars. Lenin was plainly the dictator. His image was everywhere.

Lenin decided that allowing independence to non-Russian parts of the former Russian Empire had been a mistake. It had at least helped the Reds win the Civil War when they said non-Russian countries could become independent if they wished. These countries were then eager for Red victory.

Lenin tried to reconquer Poland and failed. He did not bother with Finland, Estonia, Latvia or Lithuania. Moldova united with Romania in 1918. Again, Lenin did not order the Red Army to attempt to reconquer Moldova.

Lenin was especially keen to reconquer Azerbaijan because of its oil wealth. In 1920 the Red Army entered Azerbaijan. The Azeri Army fought the Red Army but to little avail. The Reds were better equipped that the Azeri Army. The Red Army had strong discipline reinforced by a great willingness to brutalise backsliders and indeed to execute them. Many Russians in Azerbaijan supported the Reds. There were some ethnic Azeris who welcomed the Red Army because they said that the Reds wanted to help the poor and stop exploitation by the rich.

On 28 April 1920 the Red Army entered Baku. There was later a metro station called 28 April station (it is now 28 May station). The Red Army said they were liberating Azerbaijan from the rule of a few rich men who oppressed ordinary people.

In 1919 the Bolsheviks had officially changed their name to the Communist Party. However, people continued to use the word ‘Bolshevik’ and ‘Communist’ interchangeably for many years.

Almost French – a review, kinda.


I have read most of ”Almost French” by Sarah Turnbull. She is an Australian journalist. She was in Romania briefly where she met a French lawyer a few years her senior. More or less on a whim she decided to shack up with him. She moved to Paris and the rest was a expatologue. Did I just coin a term there?

Sarah, it feels wrong to call her by her surname, says there is a well-worn genre. An Anglophone moves to a foreign land and writes about their feeling of deracination and acculturation or indeed how they are thrown back into their own identity. They then realise how this foreign country is so well, foreign.

She writes in a lively and and humourful style. There is scarcely a banal page in the book. She manages to avoid cliche except where it is warranted.

Given then this piece of autobiography is set against the background of a budding romance with a Frenchman one would have thought that there would be more about her relationship. It was odd to think that they would ‘root’ nightly as Australians say. Propriety means that the boudoir door stays very firmly shut in this book.

Her writing is innovative and informative. She manages to work a well-trodden them and while being original in her observations. She writes with admirable candour. She is not afraid to treat us to her many petty humiliations and insecurities. It is an applaudable book. Highly recommended.

Lucy Hocking – an appreciation.


I only recently saw Luck Hocking the BBC newscaster. What a tasty trifle she is. Even behind the screen I can just scent her. She would wear a mild and ladylike fragrance. She is demure but not dull. She is finely featured and perfectly formed. She is lightly made up. She does her job so well and dresses just right. She shows a flash of sternum hinting at cleavage. Her colour co-ordination is unsurpassed. Her soft New Zealand accent is so winning. What a beautiful and soulful girl. I would love to go out with her. A real sweety – intelligent, successful and a looker. An all round winning combination.

By the way I am not a stalker and live nowhere near BBC Television Centre so do not worry. Although if I did live in White City I would not be after her either. I am sure someone as gorgeous as her has a boyfriend. This is just a paean to that Antipodean siren.

Social security Darwinism.


Life expectancy in the United Kingdom is 78. The pension age is 65. This pension age needs to go up as most are fit to work well after this. Moreover, most people do desk jobs and not physical jobs now. The pension system is quite simply unsustainable with rising life expectancy. We have an overly generous welfare system paying out to the indolent.

One of the answers to the problem is smoking. Tobacco advertising ought to be allowed again. It provides pleasure to millions and its fills the nation’s coffers. Smokers on average die 13 years younger than non-smokers. If everyone smoked then life expectancy would plummet from 78 to 65 thereby making the pension system viable. Of course not everyone will smoke. I will not because I do not wish to be ill. Some people are happy to. We could give free cigarettes to pensioners. They may sell them on to younger people but this will still bring down life expectancy. Of course we will not manage to bring life expectancy down that much. The ones who will be lost will be the ones most worth losing.

I am not advocating killing people. All I saw is that people should have the choice to be healthy or not. Give them health information but do not try and scare them into behaving a certain way.

Smoking is also about social Darwinism. Studies have shown that the more intelligent a person is then the less likely they are to smoke or take drugs. Of course the reverse is also true. Those with low intelligence or mental illness are much more likely to smoke and abuse drugs.

This is also a reason to legalise drugs. If the parasitic classes wish to win a Darwin award for prematurely terminating their existence then so be it. The tattooed classes ought to have access to narcotics that are taxed to support the productive members of society. These drugs must be cheap enough to stop the chavs from stealing from respectable citizens in order to fund their drug abuse habit. We have natural selection. Now let the tattooed demographic naturally deselect themselves.

No more benefits for the underclass. Unemployment and fecklessness must no longer be a career path.

Thw way forward in Egypt.


Egypt is currently ruled by a military government. The armed forces were held in high esteem. When push came to shove they were not willing to gun down protestors in order to keep Hosni Mubarak in office. The military government was popular for a time. Now it is not so.

I thought that they ought to have proceeded as quickly as reasonably practicable to elections. These should have been held a few months ago. The suspicion is that the supreme council of the armed forces is kicking elections into the long grass. People think the military top brass is using fabian tactics. They will delay handing over power so that they can in fact cement their grip.

I think the constitution should already have been finalised and elections held. Goodwill towards the rulers is evaporating. The recrudesence of violence will ruin the Christmas tourist season. There will be no investors coming forward either.

If I were the military government I would bring politicians from different political parties into the cabinet as an interim measure. The military leaders should go on television and swear on the Qu’ran that they will step down within a specified time period and call upon people to drive them out if they do not step aside.

The situation can still be rectified. The military seems to have lost little of its old appetite for control.

A dream of derision.


I had a dream 2 nights ago of being derided by 2 former clients. One was called Miss Kudzin. I found her on the internet not long ago in real life. It was odd that she should diss me as in real life she liked me a lot. The other person was named Pippa. I detested Pippa. She and Miss Kudzin spoke of me in the most disobliging terms and disparaged my professional achievements.

Then last night I dreamt of someone named Miss Stewart making a formal complaint against me. I have seen her photo on the internet too. I am thinking of this because it is almost 3 years since a crisis in my life blew up that only recently died down.

Assad clings to office.


President Bashir al Assad is still in office. To call his dictatorial position an office is perhaps too effete. People often say that the second dynast does not call the shots. They say it is the securocrats who do. Maybe this is the myth of the good Tsar. They claim that Assad himself is not a bad man but he is just ignorant and impotent. If only he knew what was going on then he would put an end to all wrongdoing by his underlings. I find such an explanation to be deeply unconvincing.

It is estimated by reputable sources such as the UN that 3 500 people have been killed in the unrest in Syria. Unrest is too mild a word. There have been massacres. Most of the people killed have been totally unarmed, not even carrying a stone. Most have offered no violence but only chants.

I saw extracts from the Sunday Times interview with the assassin in chief. Bashir al Assad did not give a polished performance. His English was good but not perfect. He said that 800 members of the security forces had been killed. I think this is greatly exaggerated. The violence against the security forces is mostly a very recent thing.

Assad says he wants to protect people from violence. This would be risible were it not so cruelly untrue. He did not seem to recognise any wrongdoing on his part at all. He said that wrong had been done by people lower down the chain of command. He did not say he had done anything to stop this. He tried to depersonalise. he was asked how he felt about seeing people killed as he was a father. He said, ”you feel sad” rather than ”I feel sad.”

The female journalist interviewing him let him off the hook. These were softball questions. People asking for their rights have been shot dead. This is a grossly disproportionate use of force. It is hard not to call it murder.

The Arab League for once has not been totally craven only very craven. It gave him three days to ease off on the slaughter of peaceful protestors. Nothing has been done. Like Gaddafi he pretended to try dialogue. This was only a shameful ruse. It fooled nobody.

He ought to have been asked why he thinks it is evil for Israel to kill Palestinian civilians but not for Syrian forces to kill their own civilians? He claimed foreign countries were arming the militants but he did not say which countries. The less specific an allegation the less credible it is. As always the leader says the revolutionaries are foreigners or stooges of foreigners. He will not face up to the fact that the opposition are indigenous and probably have majority support. He should be asked why they have been driven to laying down their lives in huge numbers.

He says Syria needs stability. He means the stability of a cemetery.

Assad has valuable diplomatic support. Russia, Belarus, Cuba and North Korea are his allies. If I were them I would send a high level delegation to express support and give arms. This would also prove to the Arab League and others that sanctions will fail.

If he can end the demonstrations and quickly – even by a huge massacre – then he will have a good chance of survival.

The ECHR gives people the right to challenge their inclusion on the Sex Offenders’ Register.


The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) made this decision with regard to the United Kingdom a few months ago. There are two issues at play here. Should the ECHR be allowed to make a ruling on such a matter? The second question is, was this the right decision?

In my view the ECHR should not make judgments on internal affairs like this. I would let each state make up its own mind on matters of that nature. I am against the European Convention on Human Rights – I agree with many of its provisions but not with all of them. The liberty of people in the United Kingdom was already adequately protected under domestic law before the Convention was incorporated into domestic law in 1998. The Convention is always used to help the bad and harm the good.

On the other hand I agree with the decision made by the ECHR. People must be allowed to challenge government decisions. Yes, it is possible for the state to get it wrong. Therefore people must have the right of appeal against being put on the Sex Offenders’ Register. A police officer said to me, ”we all got carried away in school discos and touched girls.” He said if the girl was unahppy about it the boy could be put on the SOR.

Lord Heseltine pointed out people can be on the SOR for things they did decades ago and have never reoffended.

It ought to be difficult to be removed from the SOR but it must be possible to be removed. As it is such a stigma it also ought to be a grave matter to be put on it. We must not put people on it unjustly. I saw some youths drunk on the street on a Saturday night a few years ago. One young man pulled a moonie. The police talked to him but let him go. That was the right decision. Now he could be on the SOR because of the moral panic.

Doctors, nurses, dentists, teachers who do things that are not crimes for most people can be sent to prison and put on the SOR. A man or woman who has sex with or even kisses a 17 year old can be on the SOR for years. This is not right. Doing something consensual to a 17 year old is not the same as doing it to a 7 year old – it is not in the same league, it is not the same activity.

I remember when I did a minipupilage in 1998 I found out about a case. I shall call the man Mr Barley. Mr Barley, as a young man, had sex with a 15 year old girl. He was about 20 at the time. He was sent to prison for illegal intercourse. He went on to marry someone and have children. Then in the 1990s he son and daughter-in-law were killed in a car crash. By this time Mr Barley was about 70. He wished to adopt his grandchildren because their parents were dead. The law said he could not because of the crime he committed about 50 years before. The barrister I knew argued that Barley ought to be allowed to adopt his grandchildren as he posed no danger to them. It was be excessively cautious and too vindictive to bar him from so doing. The barrister was not just arguing this for professional and financial reasons. He sincerely believed in the justice of what he was doing.

There are people who deserve to be on the SOR. There are some who should remain there for life. Some people commit ghastly crimes of this kind and need to be harshly punished with years of imprisonment – maybe even decades in the case of serial offenders. However, we must have proportionality and commonsense – not a knee jerk reaction.